A different prospective

As we trawl through the heaps of reports winging their way into our in-boxes, in an effort to make some sense of the last few days, I append below some of the more interesting comments for those clients who can summon the courage to refelct on events.

Defaqto say "Speculators, who for so long pushed up the price of oil, pushed it down.

In all the hullabaloo of recent months, two laws have been forgotten. Rule 1: In the long-term, price is determined by demand and supply. Rule 2: Demand falls with price. (Or as an economist would say, the demand curve slopes downwards from left to right.)

In the short-term, demand, for oil and, as it also appears, for houses, is quite inelastic – meaning that demand is not affected by price. But in the long-term this is not the case. As price goes up, demand stays put, the economy suffers. Then demand falls, and price begins to fall too. The economy recovers.

Some said that the bail out of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac marked the turning point of the credit crunch. Events of the last few days have surely shown how wrong this view was.

Some said the failure of Lehman Brothers heralded the turning point. Yesterday’s fall in shares surely shows how wrong that piece of analysis was.

But yesterday’s fall in oil is a different matter altogether – and provides the single biggest reason to expect recovery."

Edward Bonham Carter of Jupiter comments: -

"These events are likely to shake confidence in the financial system and lead to a fall in inflation. One would expect economic confidence to take another knock as a result, and the probability of interest rate cuts to increase. Without rate cuts, the coming economic recession will be significantly exacerbated.

History will judge whether the Fed's decision not to save Lehman proves to be the correct one. Such inaction suggests that for the effective operation of shareholder capitalism, firms must be allowed to fail.

The authorities are placing belief in the proposition that an investment bank such as Lehman can go out of business without triggering widespread panic in the rest of the system. At the same time, it remains the key role of authorities in the US, Europe and the UK to ensure that while shareholders are exposed, individual depositors and the banking system are protected. Confidence in these must be maintained above all else.

As yet, it is too early to establish what the full consequences of these events will be. However, the stock market is likely to remain volatile and investor confidence fragile as the true impact of these events and the wider effect on economic growth is assessed.

However, while the investment environment remains volatile, investors should recognise that it is in these sort of conditions that significant investment opportunities can emerge. As such, they can present a buying opportunity for those prepared to take a long term view. It is also in such volatile conditions that the practice of drip-feeding investments into the stock market through regular savings schemes can prove beneficial."

After studying column after column it is clear that going forward the outlook remains extremely difficult to call. Over the next twenty four hours we may have further significant events from policy makers with aggressive US interest rate cuts now being priced in by markets, starting from tomorrow’s FOMC meeting. The market has moved to a near certainty that rates will be cut. If this is the case, it is likely that the Bank of England and the ECB will follow, in part to avoid currency overvaluation and even bigger internal economic problems.

Liquidity is being pumped into the financial system but, like similar previous occasions this and last year, it’s not enough – risk and borrowing aversion remains at high levels. In the short term, it is likely that risk assets will continue to suffer while safe haven bonds will benefit.

In summary we believe that the short term will be tough for equities and credits and there is a good chance of further downside in prices in coming days. Lehman Brothers has proven that the bar for those ‘too big to fail’ has just been raised.

For the majority of our clients we are still recommending "sit tight" as long as investment are diversified across asset class and sectors. We appreciate the concerns everyone is facing just now.